Faith & Social Justice: In the spirit of Richard Overton and the 17th C. Levellers

Today in Church History: Pope Initiates “Great Schism.”

16 July 1054 Pope Leo IX excommunicates Michael Cerularius, the Patriarch of Constantinople.  Four days later, the Patriarch will respond by excommunicating Pope Leo in return.  This is the final initiation of the “Great Schism” between Eastern and Western Christianity.  The issues had been broiling for some time:  The Eastern Churches were concerned (rightly, it seems to me) with the addition of the filioque to the Nicene Creed. (That is, the addition of the phrase which says that the Holy Spirit proceeds not only from the Father, but also “from the Son.” The Western/Catholic Church believed the phrase necessary to preserve the unity of the Trinity. The Eastern/Orthodox Churches believed the addition introduced a dangerous subordinationism into the Godhead. I believe the East had the better argument.) They were also concerned that the filioque was added directly by the pope instead of being decided by an ecumenical council. The Western Church believed that the pope was the head of the church, the Vicar of Christ on earth, whereas the Eastern Church held all the bishops to have equal authority, with the bishop of Rome being, at best, “first among equals.”

As a Free Church Protestant, I am not comfortable with either Catholicism or Orthodoxy in their view of ecclesial authority.  But I think blame for the Great Schism clearly lies more with Rome than with Constantinople.


July 16, 2007 - Posted by | church history


  1. Free Church? As in, free from liturgy? My brother, there is no such thing. Liturgy is part of being human I think. Thee free churches simply live under the illusion that they have no liturgy, but illusion is not reality. We all have a liturgy. The question, in the end, is, who has the best liturgy?

    Love the web site.

    Comment by abu daoud | July 20, 2007

  2. No, the term “Free Church” is not used to refer to liturgy. It refers to those denominations which are intentionally without any legal ties to any government(i.e., not only not “established” anywhere, but not wanting establishment for anyone) and which do not have area bishops, but each congregation is free to shape its life together according to its understanding of the Holy Spirit’s leading regarding its mission. Free Church denominations include Mennonites, Baptists, most Pentecostal groups, Nazarenes, etc.

    So, there was no question about “who has the best liturgy,” regarding the Great Schism or my view of the same.

    Comment by Michael Westmoreland-White | July 20, 2007

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

%d bloggers like this: