Thought for the Day
“We have always known that greed was bad morality; what we have learned is that greed is also bad economics.” Franklin D. Roosevelt, 1933.
July 20, 2009 - Posted by Michael Westmoreland-White | Uncategorized
3 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
About
Michael L. Westmoreland-White, Ph.D. I live in Louisville, KY USA with my wife, Kate, and our two wonderful daughters. My wife, Kate, is a Baptist minister who works at a Catholic charity (the Society of St. Vincent de Paul) to provide assisted housing to homeless people. Our daughters are Molly (’95) and Miriam (’99). I am a former soldier converted to gospel nonviolence and a once (and future?) academic theologian turned peace activist, author, and peace educator. Contact me at mlw-w@insightbb.com
The Levellers were a 17th C. movement during the English Civil War. They were a religiously-inspired political movement for democracy, human rights, justice for the poor, and peace. Their strongest leader was Richard Overton, a pacifist General Baptist influenced by Dutch Mennonites. Although I write on a wide range of topics, most often this blog deals with the intersection of faith, especially Christian faith, and work for social justice and peace. So, I have named the blog and dedicated it to the spirit of Richard Overton and the 17th C. Levellers.
Rules for commenting on this blog: 1) Respect everyone, even when you disagree strongly. 2) Keep comments relatively short. If you need a long post on your own blog, I’ll follow you there to see what more you have to say. 3) Stay on topic, please. 4) Don’t hog the conversation; let others have a turn. 5) This is a family-friendly blog. No profanity or language that my children and your children cannot read, please. Failure to follow these simple rules could lead me to removing your comment(s).
Christian Peace Bloggers
Baptist Bloggers
Baptist Bloggers
Join | List | Previous | Next | Random | Previous 5 | Next 5 | Skip Previous | Skip Next-
Blog Stats
- 498,550 hits
Biblio-Blogs
Blogroll
Religious Social Criticism
- A Thinking Reed
- Avdat
- Baptist Voices for Peace and Justice
- Big Daddy Weave
- Bruce Prescott
- Confessions of a Recovering Pharisee
- Cramer Comments
- Doing Theology from the Caribbean
- Earth as it is in Heaven
- FORpeace
- Fors Clavigera
- Global Perspectives
- God's Politics
- Good God: Faith for the Rest of Us
- Hopeful Daniel
- I Saw It In Palestine
- Intellectuelle
- J. C. Baker
- Jesus Politics
- Mainstream Baptists
- Mystical Politics
- Never Give Up
- On Journeying with Those in Exile
- On the Homefront
- Pam BG’s Blog
- Peaceable Zealot
- Ponderings on a Faith Journey
- Return Good for Evil
- Sandalstraps’ Sanctuary
- Sean the Baptist
- Sepherim
- Sub Ratione Dei
- Telling the Stories That Matter
- Texas in Africa
- The Episcoptist Chronicles
- The Great Swalmi
- The Jesus Manifesto
- The Prophetic Edge
- The Quakers’ Colonel
- Theopolitical
- Through the Woods
- Vindicated
- Words from Washington
Theology Blogs
- A Greater Courage
- Anabaptist Studies
- Baptist Voices for Peace and Justice
- Confessions of a Recovering Pharisee
- Connexions
- Cramer Comments
- Doing Theology from the Caribbean
- Dr. Platypus
- Earth as it is in Heaven
- Exiled Preacher
- Faith & Theology
- Flying Farther
- Fors Clavigera
- Gifts of God
- Global Perspectives
- God in a Shrinking Universe
- Good God: Faith for the Rest of Us
- Hopeful Daniel
- Imaginary Grace
- Inhabitatio Dei
- Intellectuelle
- J. C. Baker
- Jesus Creed
- Jesus Politics
- Leaving Munster [Graham Old]
- LeRon Shults
- Life at Jeff Street
- Maggi Dawn
- Missions and Theology
- Nothing New Under the Sun
- On Journeying with Those in Exile
- Pam BG’s Blog
- Peaceable Zealot
- Per Caritatem
- Reading Yoder
- Return Good for Evil
- Sandalstraps’ Sanctuary
- Sub Ratione Dei
- The Bonhoefferian
- The Episcoptist Chronicles
- The Fire and the Rose
- The Great Swalmi
- The Ivy Bush
- The Jesus Manifesto
- The Magdelene Mystique
- The Prophetic Edge
- The View From This Seat
- Theopolitical
- Trinitarian Soundings
- Trinities
- Vindicated
- Words from Washington
Pages
Where Are My Readers?
-
Recent Posts
Top Posts
- Contest: The Top Living Theologians
- The Practice of Theology, 3: Branches of Theology
- Two Types of Christian Pacifism
- A Brief History of the Fellowship of Reconciliation
- My Top 25 Favorite Fictional Detectives
- Conscientious Objectors During World War II
- JPT Practice # 7: Work with Emerging Cooperative Forces in the International System
- An Appreciation of the Family Niebuhr
- Howard Thurman: The Mystic as Prophet
- Fictional Clergy Detectives III
Recent Comments
Archives
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
- September 2006
- August 2006
- July 2006
- June 2006
- July 2005
- June 2005
- May 2005
- April 2005
Categories
- abortion
- Afghanistan
- Africa
- American Friends Service Committee
- anabaptists
- antisemitism
- arts
- assassination
- atheism
- atonement
- authority
- autobiography
- baptism
- Baptists
- Bible
- Biblical exegesis
- biography
- blog-ring
- Blogroll
- blogs
- books
- Catholic social teaching
- child welfare
- Christian calendar
- Christian zionism.
- Christianity
- Christmas
- church
- church history
- church-state separation
- citizenship
- civil liberties
- consumerism
- convictions
- courts
- criminal juste
- criminal justice
- death penalty
- democracy
- detective fiction
- discipleship
- Easter
- ecology
- economic justice
- ecumenism
- education
- elections
- empire
- entertainment
- ethics
- eucharist
- evangelicals
- evangelism
- faith
- family
- fantasy fiction
- feminism
- films
- foreign policy
- forgiveness
- Friends (Quakers)
- fundamentalists
- gender
- GLBT issues
- global warming
- government
- guns
- healthcare
- Hebrew Bible/O.T.
- heroes
- Historic Peace Churches
- holocaust
- Holy Spirit
- homosexuality
- hope
- human rights.
- humor
- hymns
- incarnation
- interfaith
- Iran
- Iraq
- Islam
- Israel
- Israel-Palestine
- Jesus
- Jews
- Jimmy Carter
- John Howard Yoder
- Judaism
- judges
- judicial philosophy
- just peacemaking
- just war theory
- Kingdom of God
- labor
- law
- liberal theology
- liberation
- liturgy
- logic
- love of enemies
- materialism
- media reform
- mentors
- messiah
- ministry
- MLK
- moral discernment
- music
- myths
- New Testament
- nonviolence
- nuclear weapons
- Obituaries
- pacifism
- passions
- peace
- peacemaking
- philosophy
- politics
- popular culture
- poverty
- prayer
- prejudice
- professional societies
- progressive faith
- race
- Reformation
- religious liberty
- Religious Social Criticism
- resurrection
- saints
- salvation
- scandal
- science & faith
- science-fiction
- Sermon on the Mount
- sexism
- sin
- slavery
- social history
- taxes
- terrorism prevention
- testimony
- the tragic
- theological education
- theology
- torture
- tradition
- U.S. politics
- Uncategorized
- violence
- virgin birth
- virtues
- war
- women
- young people
Of course in 1933, leaders like Roosevelt weren’t just reflecting their disappointment with the contracting economy after the speculative greed of the 20’s. That is the way someone on the left reads this now. Liberals in that day had one eye on the Soviet system and its impressive rational planned economy. Roosevelt had many similar policies brewing as he entered office. This rhetoric was employed towards implementing those plans. Some of the more radical plans were in fact attempted and became quickly forgotten failures when compared to his otherwise successful legacy.
After Stalin turned out a murderous tyrant achieving efficiency by starving the Ukraine, agendas were trimmed back and economists like Keynes turned from planning and redistribution to merely moderating the swings in the business cycle and providing a modest safety net.
Just a little context for an otherwise nice thought.
Except that it’s mostly wrong, Stan. Roosevelt NEVER had his eye on the USSR as a model. He came from wealth and entered office still very conservative. He had no idea of a planned economy and was cautious with the programs of the New Deal–to the end he refused to nationalize the banks, although even the bankers would have cheered in 1933 as their banks were collapsing around their ears. Roosevelt had to be pushed into taking Keynesian measures (when John Maynard Keynes visited from England, he found FDR remarkably ignorant about economics) and only slowly became what we, today, would call “liberal.” What he had was a willingness to experiment–a fierce pragmatism.
He also had to contend with a strong Socialist movement on the one hand and many Fascists on the other. When he was inaugurated in March 1933, democracies were collapsing across the world and newspapers here were urging that FDR be given dictatorial powers. He refused and later, when he would have overstepped, Congress and the Supreme Court found themselves remembering they were separate and equal parts of government.
Read Jonathan Alter’s bestsellar about FDR and the New Deal, The Defining Moment.
I really believe that greed can decimate a person. Thank God I have always had the basics – food, shelter and a good family. Those things to me are worth more than gold.